"That mask...That's not the mask he was wearing!"
Izabel started. "W-what?! But...this is the Blue Badger's mas-"

"You think I don't know what I saw? I may be old but my eyes are as good as ever! 'Eagle-eyed Wendy' they'd call me when I was a girl, and believe me I earned it! I could pick out a good man from across the dance hall before the other girls even had their eyes open! And I know what I saw: The mask he was wearing had
pure black eyes!"
Fischer nodded. "Ah, I understand what happened here...Annabeth, take a look at this."

"Now...what do you think Miss Oldbag saw?"